Skip to main content
Physical/Tech

The Benjamini-Hochberg procedure can fail to control the FDR for correlated two-sided Gaussian tests.

| Source: Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America

The Benjamini-Hochberg (BH) procedure is the standard method for controlling the false discovery rate (FDR) in large-scale studies involving testing multiple hypotheses. Whether the BH procedure controls the FDR for every correlation structure among two-sided Gaussian tests has been a long-standing question, and a positive answer has been believed. Here, we settle the question negatively, by providing examples of Gaussian factor models for which the BH method fails to control the FDR at the nomi

The Benjamini-Hochberg (BH) procedure is the standard method for controlling the false discovery rate (FDR) in large-scale studies involving testing multiple hypotheses. Whether the BH procedure controls the FDR for every correlation structure among two-sided Gaussian tests has been a long-standing question, and a positive answer has been believed. Here, we settle the question negatively, by providing examples of Gaussian factor models for which the BH method fails to control the FDR at the nominal level. We prove mathematically that the violation holds, and also provide simulation results which are consistent with the theory. The level of violation can be characterized as mild but nonnegligible. In one of our examples, empirical FDR levels of ≈0.0106 and ≈0.053 are achieved for nominal FDR levels 0.01 and 0.05, respectively. Larger violations are also possible. The violation appears most prominently for large numbers (thousands) of tests; though we also present an example with a moderate number of 85 tests. We also briefly discuss the implications of our findings.

Read the original source →

Related Stories

Physical/Tech

Extensive glacier loss in the coterminous United States.

Glaciers populate the mountain ranges of the western conterminous United States and despite their importance to alpine hydrology, their area and volume change have never been comprehensively evaluated. Our study shows that since the mid-twentieth century about one-quarter of the glaciers have disappeared and the overall area and volume are reduced by one-third. The pattern of glacier shrinkage suggests most glaciers in the conterminous United States are largely maintained by local topographic in

Continue reading
Physical/Tech

Reaction-based cryo-EM resolves the continuous conformational spectrum of CTP synthase catalysis.

Capturing enzymes under native turnover conditions remains a grand challenge in structural biology. Here, we develop a reaction-based cryo-electron microscopy (cryo-EM) strategy that directly samples Drosophila melanogaster cytidine triphosphate synthase (CTPS) from actively catalyzing mixtures containing only natural substrates and allosteric effectors. By integrating reaction-based sampling with three-dimensional variability analysis, we resolve a continuous conformational spectrum of CTPS dur

Continue reading
Physical/Tech

GTP orchestrates CTP synthase via an allosteric effector-cycling mechanism.

Cytidine triphosphate (CTP), a fundamental building block of RNA, plays vital roles in diverse biological processes. CTP synthase (CTPS) is the only known enzyme for de novo synthesis of CTP. Efficient CTPS catalysis requires guanosine triphosphate (GTP) in a dose-dependent, nonconsumptive manner; however, the precise mechanism by which GTP drives CTP formation remains unclear. Here, we integrate a series of cryo-EM structures of Drosophila melanogaster CTPS captured from actively catalyzing sam

Continue reading
Physical/Tech

Antiferromagnetism and tightly bound Cooper pairs induced by kinetic frustration.

Antiferromagnetism and superconductivity are often viewed as competing orders in correlated electron systems. Here, we demonstrate that kinetic frustration in hole motion facilitates their coexistence within the square-lattice repulsive Hubbard model. Combining exact analytical solutions on tailored geometries with large-scale numerical simulations, we reveal a robust pairing mechanism: Holes on opposite sublattices behave as if they carry opposite effective charges due to spin singlet formation

Continue reading
Physical/Tech

Coordinated transformations of the labyrinth and occiput during the dinosaur-bird transition.

Evolutionary shape changes of the vertebrate semicircular canals (SCCs) are often ascribed to evolutionary transitions in locomotion, including the origin of flight during the dinosaur-bird transition. However, the potential for transformations of braincase architecture to influence SCC shape independent of sensory-functional adaptation has generally been overlooked. We evaluate the influence of both factors using a large dataset of 146 living and recently extinct crown birds, including taxa rep

Continue reading